Net worth projection

Pay off debt or save? How to compare the two with numbers

Every extra payment on a debt and every deposit into savings raises net worth by the same amount on the day you make it. What differs is what happens next: the interest you avoid, the return you might earn and how much cash you keep for emergencies.

Both raise net worth today

Paying 500 off a card lowers debts by 500. Putting 500 into savings raises assets by 500. Either way, net worth rises by 500 at once. The choice is about the months and years after that.

What a debt costs over time

The Federal Reserve’s 2025 survey report notes that the average market interest rate on credit cards rose from 14.6% in 2022 to 21.4% in 2025. Here is what a 5,000 balance at that rate costs with different fixed monthly payments and no new spending on the card:

Paying off 5,000 at 21.4% a year
Monthly paymentMonths to pay offTotal interest
150522,658.66
200341,679.35
35017823.13
40015707.98

Moving from 150 to 350 a month saves 1,835.53 in interest and clears the debt almost three years sooner.

Interest paid on 5,000 at 21.4% by monthly payment Bar chart of total interest: paying 150 a month costs 2,659 in interest over 52 months; 200 a month, 1,679 over 34 months; 350 a month, 823 over 17 months; 400 a month, 708 over 15 months. 2,659150 / month52 months 1,679200 / month34 months 823350 / month17 months 708400 / month15 months
Calculated with monthly interest of 21.4% ÷ 12 on the remaining balance.

Comparing an extra payment with saving

An extra payment on a debt “earns” the interest rate you stop paying, and that saving is certain as long as the balance would otherwise remain. A savings account pays a known rate that is usually lower than card rates. Investments may earn more or less, with no guarantee. Comparing the two is a matter of comparing rates, risk and flexibility:

Factors to weigh
FactorPaying debt downSaving
ReturnThe debt’s interest rate, avoidedThe account or investment return, which may vary
CertaintyCertain while the debt remainsFixed for deposits; uncertain for investments
Access to the moneyGone once paid, unless you can borrow againAvailable for emergencies
Employer match or tax benefitsNot applicableMay apply to some retirement accounts

Questions that shape the answer for you

  • What is the interest rate on each debt, and is it fixed or variable?
  • Do you have any cash set aside for emergencies? The CFPB describes an emergency fund as a cash reserve set aside for unplanned expenses or financial emergencies; see how much to save for an emergency fund.
  • Does your employer add money to retirement contributions?
  • Are there penalties for early repayment?
  • Would paying off the debt free up cash flow you would then save?

Many people split their spare money between the two. We do not recommend a particular split: it depends on your rates, job security and goals, and a qualified adviser can help with your situation.

How our projection treats debt

The projection calculator reduces the debt with your monthly payment and charges monthly interest on what remains. When the debt is paid off, it does not automatically move that payment into savings. If you plan to do that, raise the monthly contribution in a second run to see the effect. See how to project your net worth.

Questions people ask

Does paying off debt improve net worth faster than saving?

Only through the interest. On the day of payment, both have the same effect. Over time, avoiding a high rate usually adds more than a lower savings rate, but investment returns are uncertain.

What if my net worth is negative?

A negative figure is common in some stages of life. See negative net worth for what it means and how people track the way back to zero.

Sources

  1. Federal Reserve Board, Changes in U.S. Family Finances from 2022 to 2025: the rise in average credit card interest rates between 2022 and 2025.
  2. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, An essential guide to building an emergency fund.

Educational information only. This page compares numbers; it is not a recommendation to pay down debt or to save.

Related guides